Page 1 of 1

Devil's advocate

Posted: Sat Jan 10, 2026 6:23 pm
by Undercover
The thing about "statutory rape" is that you'll be imprisoned for consensual sex, so if you're automatically treated as a villain no matter what you do, then why not just embrace the villain and become an actual rapist? The law doesn't care and will give you the same prison sentence anyway. Note that I'm not encouraging sexual violence; I'm just trying to make a point

Re: Devil's advocate

Posted: Sat Jan 10, 2026 9:53 pm
by Not Forever
Undercover wrote: Sat Jan 10, 2026 6:23 pm The thing about "statutory rape" is that you'll be imprisoned for consensual sex, so if you're automatically treated as a villain no matter what you do, then why not just embrace the villain and become an actual rapist? The law doesn't care and will give you the same prison sentence anyway. Note that I'm not encouraging sexual violence; I'm just trying to make a point
It’s a bit like when people call for rape to be punished with the same penalties as murder: in practice, at a certain point it would be in the rapist’s interest to kill the victim. Clearly, proportionality in sentencing has its usefulness in discouraging the escalation of such scenarios.

Re: Devil's advocate

Posted: Sat Apr 04, 2026 2:23 am
by Creature Bipedal
Literally, rape is kidnapping. Fucking someone unconscious is not rape, but dating a child without parental permission is considered as kidnapping in some legislations.

Re: Devil's advocate

Posted: Wed Jul 29, 2026 9:57 pm
by Hiago
Creature Bipedal wrote: Sat Apr 04, 2026 2:23 am Literally, rape is kidnapping. Fucking someone unconscious is not rape, but dating a child without parental permission is considered as kidnapping in some legislations.
I find it weird how, even when some legislations allow it, someone else’s permission (from the parents) its needed before for a relationship, even when the child wants it. It’s almost as if children aren’t seen as human beings in this world.

Re: Devil's advocate

Posted: Thu Jul 30, 2026 2:47 am
by weird.organisms
Hiago wrote: Wed Jul 29, 2026 9:57 pm
Creature Bipedal wrote: Sat Apr 04, 2026 2:23 am Literally, rape is kidnapping. Fucking someone unconscious is not rape, but dating a child without parental permission is considered as kidnapping in some legislations.
I find it weird how, even when some legislations allow it, someone else’s permission (from the parents) its needed before for a relationship, even when the child wants it. It’s almost as if children aren’t seen as human beings in this world.
Yep! Slaves of the adults!

Re: Devil's advocate

Posted: Sun Aug 02, 2026 8:49 am
by CantChainTheSpirit
That's the problem with punishment becomes disproportionate. It's like the three-strikes law in the United States where someone gets a life sentence for a third conviction even if it wouldn't normally lead to a life sentence, in which case if you're going to break the law a third time then it might as well be all out, there's no point getting life for something small.

But the case of statutory rape is a perfect example, if it's rape whether you have consent or not then why bother about consent? At this point it's just down to personal conviction, how important consent it personally, so it's a system that openly admits it just hopes that rapists will be nice people and not actually rape before they're convicted for it.